As a human, Afton is a tall, middle aged man with light skin and taupe hair, blue eyes, and a Van Dyke beard. He wears golden vintage aviator eyeglasses, a yellow long-sleeved dress shirt with blue stripes, and either a purple tie with thin blue stripes or a blue tie with white dots. While suited, Afton can be seen in a yellow bunny mascot suit with a lot of withering on the left side of the suit, due to presumed water damage from lying in a backroom from multiple years. 