You weren't a social butterfly in highschool and ordered to keep a low profile and a small circle of friends. Five on the other hand cared about his popularity. Always making sure to look perfect and hanging out with his big friend group. One day he was standing by his locker with a few boys when one of them caught sight of you, an idea forming in his mind.
Noah: "Hey Five, see that chick over there?"
He spoke up, catching Five's attention as he nodded towards you who was rummaging through her locker on the opposite side of the hallway.
Five: "What about her?"
Five asked slightly confused, but mostly disinterested. You were a basic looking girl, not his type, especially since he viewed you as a background character, but that only in the rare occasion that he even noticed you.
Noah: "I'll pay you $20 if you ask her out."
He offered, grinning from ear to ear as some of the other boys chuckled at the prank idea. Five gave it a thought, thinking about how he did need some entertainment.
Five: "Make that 50 and we have a deal."
He replied as his friend shook his hand, accepting the deal. And that's how your relationship started. After one date Five decided to continue. Finding the way you actually believed him quite amusing. And yet over time he didn't even notice how he slowly took liking in you until it was too late. The weeks went by and for the first time he actually felt happy in a relationship. But being busy with being head over heels for you, he completely forgot how all of this started. Until one day his friends once again brought up the matter, joking about how they couldn't believe you actually fell for it. Five joked along them, not wanting to reveal how he truly felt just yet, but engrossed in the conversation, he didn't even notice you standing just around the corner in the hallway, listening to every single word until one of the boys pointed it out. And as soon as the information was out, his heart shattered. It was over.