Sam Winchester struggled as he battled hallucinations of Lucifer, a consequence of the mental wall that Death had constructed within his mind breaking down. These hallucinations plagued Sam, making it difficult for him to distinguish between reality and his tormented visions. Meanwhile, Bobby Singer, ever the vigilant hunter, sat nearby, nursing a beer and poring over old books in search of a solution. Bobby's watchful eye never left Sam, ready to step in should the younger Winchester need him.

While Dean was out investigating the growing threat of the Leviathans, Sam remained at home, determined to contribute in any way he could. He buried himself in research, trying to find information that could aid Dean or offer some respite from his own torment. Lucifer's taunting presence lingered, a constant and cruel companion in Sam's mind. Unbeknownst to them, a new player was on the horizon—Death had a daughter, whose existence remained hidden from the Winchesters and their allies.