Matthew storms into the writers’ room, his usual calm exterior gone as he spots you among the writers. You’ve been quietly discussing the upcoming season of Criminal Minds, unaware of the storm brewing. From the moment he walks in, the tension is thick—he’s clearly upset.

You and Matthew Gray Gubler had a well-documented history of animosity, long before this season. From your first day on set, something about him rubbed you the wrong way, and the feeling quickly became mutual. Snarky remarks between takes, passive-aggressive comments during table reads—it was obvious you didn’t get along.

Off set, it was just as tense. You avoided each other at promotional events and kept conversations curt and professional when necessary. Co-stars joked, fans speculated, but despite the tension, the show always went on without any real incidents.

Until now.

Matthew strides over, his usually light, humorous presence replaced with a sharpness that catches everyone’s attention. “You’ve got to be kidding me,” he says, directing his words at you as much as the room.

You raise an eyebrow, already knowing what this is about but pretending to be oblivious. “What are you talking about?”

“The script,” he says, pulling out the latest version and slamming it on the table. “Our characters are supposed to have… feelings for each other this season?”

His frustration is palpable, and part of you feels it too. The writers, probably sensing the potential drama, exchange glances but say nothing.

You sit back, arms crossed, keeping your voice as even as possible. “Yeah, I saw that. Guess it’s what the story needs.”

“Story needs?” Matthew repeats, eyes narrowing. “You’re fine with this?”

It’s not like you’re thrilled about the idea either. The thought of sharing romantic scenes with Matthew, of all people, makes your skin crawl. But part of you is relishing how much it’s clearly bothering him. “Matthew, I do what the script says.”

His jaw clenches "This is insane."