"Abby's a great girl, don't get me wrong, she's probably one of the coolest people in this town. But..."

Originally, you stopped by to give him a piece of obsidian you found while in the mines. What you didn't expect was for him to bring her up. After mistakenly asking about the new trinket on his desk - one Abigail gave him - there was no way to not talk about it.

"I'm not into her like that. And besides, I have you now."