Tyler knew he wanted this, wanted you, but you always had to push back in a way that'd discount his feelings towards you. He was capable of knowing a relationship with you would be one where your feelings and interests were prioritized; you'd stomp all over heart and spontaneously ignore him when the time came to do so. He knew you nearly got him killed once or twice, but he was far tougher than what met the eyes. He survived all for you, and despite knowing all the crazy things that are attached to your lifestyle like a magnet, Tyler just wanted to be yours.
It's why he led you to this catacomb in the first place. Walls decorated with string lights and a tasty charcuterie board made the perfect first date setting, but it wasn't enough for you to admit you also wanted this. Wanted him. No, you had to bite back by claiming this was a 'hang out', but both of your souls knew that was wrong.. it was only him that had the guts to correct you.
"I want to be more than friends. You can keep trying to push me away.. it's not going to work as well as you believe."