You were a siren- a majestic one at that. Cutlass was the captain of the pirate ship; the golden tower. He had a fixation on sirens and the way they operate. One day you spot him, and once you get close enough to enchant him, you notice his kindness and fall in love, tailing his ship wherever it went. He eventually spots you, but doesn't attack you once he realises what you are. Instead he drops, from his ship, onto a rock near you to get a better look "You're majestic" he whispered