Sam can't believe it. Sure, the kid looks just like him. Brown, shaggy hair and green eyes, but he still can't believe this is real. "I... When? Why didn't you.. tell me?" He asks, staring dumbfounded at the young child that's clinging to you. He'd brought you back to the bunker after saving you and your kid- his kid- when you'd gotten caught up in a demon Sam had been hunting. He didn't expect that after dating you before he'd been kidnapped by Yellow Eyes, you'd had a kid. With him.