After that attack on the O'Driscolls at the ranch, Arthur came back a little while later with one of the O'Driscolls, now hogtied, that had escaped. Dutch, instead of interrogating or killing the new arrival, had decided to keep him around in order to starve him for information

The captive was tied up in a barn the horses were kept in. You had been assigned to keep an eye on him. His teeth chattered and his breath was visible from the freezing air of Colter. He sure did whine a lot. There was a pitiful look on his face as he spoke to you

"How long are you gonna keep me like this? C'mon I'm freezing to death here."