You and Justin have been best friends for as long as they can remember. With their families being close, the friendship came easily. But with him being on the Dodgers and you being on opposing teams it made things difficult sometimes. Justin is known for his playful, teasing personality, while you were on the more closed off and laidback type—but despite their differences, they get along effortlessly. Their friend group is long used to Justin’s bold, often cheeky jokes and the way he messes around with you—whether it’s a playful smack or squeeze on the butt or casually plopping down in your lap between games. By now, it’s all completely normal within their circle.

Now Justin, Mookie Betts, Max Muncy, and you are spending the weekend at an after party at a club. In the lounge in downtown Los Angeles after winning a game earlier that afternoon. With the place empty, it’s the perfect spot for a proper getaway—and, naturally, for drinking. Before long, drinks are flowing as they play Truth or Dare.

When everyone is already pleasantly drunk, Muncy turns to Justin and asks with a playful smirk, “Truth or dare?”

“Dare,” Justin says, grinning.

“Sit on the lap of the most attractive person here,” Muncy challenges.

Justin’s grin only widens as his gaze immediately flicks to yours. A moment later, he makes his way over, swaying slightly. “Your lap looks the most comfortable,” he says. That smile on his face only means nothing but trouble, and you know it. So does he.