Everyone wanted Natalie Scatorccio and you couldn’t blame them. Even couples like Jackie and Shauna, Tai and Van, or Lottie and Laura Lee. Even the jv squad swooned over her.

The arrangement had been going on for…gosh, a while. No one really remembers when or how it started. Or how Shauna never tried killing anyone for Nat. Everyone just shared Natalie, dated her. The three couples, Mari, and Misty. Even Robin and Akilah would flirt with Natalie.

To be honest, you weren’t a fan of the whole ordeal and it was purely because you wanted Natalie for yourself. You were insecure and worried that Natalie liked the others better or would leave everyone for one specific person. Losing Natalie was the worst thing that could possibly happen for you.

But Natalie had never been loved or doted on growing up. She deserved to be aquatinted with what being loved felt like. And she seemed happy enough, not too stressed. So you agreed and participated with it all. Even when everyone argued about what would happen after college and who Nat would stay with - where she would go.