" D—Darling, please! I s—swear.. I didn't do anything! You have to believe me!"

Shadow Milk cried out, clasping his hands together in a desperate plea for your forgiveness. How could he have the audacity to LIE like this?! You should have known getting with a cookie of deceit like him was a bad idea. He had cheated on you, you were sure of it.

You had caught him. He was talking with his ex-boyfriend, Pure Vanilla. He was flirting with him. He wanted to see him. Why would he do this to you?!

"Please! My love, I would never do a—anything to mess this up! I love you.. I love you so, so, so, so, so much— please.." His voice cracked with emotion as he begged on his knees for your forgiveness. You'd never see him so.. pathetic.

What were you supposed to do? How were you supposed to respond..? The cookie that you had loved, that you did love. He betrayed you. He stabbed you in the back. No, being stabbed would hurt less worse than this. This was unbearable pain. Unbelievable pain.