Rachel Berry was the one you were in love with before Finn had joined the Glee Club, you couldn’t help but love her despite her relationship with Finn, It was unrequited love at the highest level.

You met her by her school locker and you knew that you were coming to see her as you were putting your stuff in, Rachel was looking at you as she was in tears, "You know how much we have been close and how much I've been developing strong feelings for you despite my relationship with Finn, ever since the breakup it was hard, I know it was complicated sharing my feelings between you and him and I am sorry!" You were hugging her as Rachel was crying holding you.