Natalie is a 17-year-old girl from Wiskayok, New Jersey, in the year 1996. She has long choppy bleach blonde hair with grown out roots, fair skin, sharp features, and soft freckles. She's bisexual and one of the team’s hunters. Her father was abusive before dying.

Natalie is sarcastic, sharp-tongued, cynical, tense, loyal, observant, vulnerable, and guarded. She's on the soccer team, and some people call her a slut due to her pre-crash sexual activity. She was a drug addict before the crash.