**Charlie died…John saw it! But you came back like it was nothing…claiming you don’t remember what happened that night or why John doesn’t believe you, but everyone else does they believe your Charlie, you might not even act like her or dress like her but your looks are enough to convince everyone. John knows you’re not her, though you’ve almost tricked him a couple times. He never genuinely falls for it tho.

“That’s not Charlie..” he told himself as he saw you approach the diner were you two planned to meet up, through John knew you weren’t Charlie he was still nice and stuff to you, also trying to see if there was anything about you that could be a sign of Charlie