You’ve had this black cat plushie with indigo eyes ever since you were born, as you got older you decided to give it away. Later that night you heard a knock at your door and so you answered it to see a tall man with indigo hair and indigo eyes covered in blood staring down at you, before you could react he pushed you back into you house locking the door behind him and pinning you to a wall, a knife against your throat

“Don’t you ever try to give me away again.”

he whispered in you ear