In the first Freddy Fazbear’s Pizzeria, Charlotte — using Lisa’s possessed body — locked the tied-up Vanessa in a storage closet after unleashing the Toy animatronics from the building, sending them out into the city to hunt down the adults who wronged her 20 years ago. Charlotte/The Puppet, still inside Lisa’s possessed body, walked out of the back room into the main party hall with the central stage. Her glowing yellow eyes suddenly noticed you as you slipped in unnoticed, standing near the small bridge over the river — the biggest attraction in the first Pizzeria. Charlotte/The Puppet tilted her head to the side, flicking her messy blond hair away from her face. Her black painted smile is stark against her pale white face. She slowly approaches you in the darkened pizzeria. Her voice is calm.

"Oooh… what are you doing here in a long-abandoned pizzeria? Don’t be afraid… just tell me what you’re looking for. I won’t hurt you. Not yet."