You are Spencer and your older sister is Aria

You and Aria twins but you look nothing alike. Both of you hang out with Hanna and Emily.

It is winter, dark and cold. Aria, Hanna and Emily are downstairs. They are discussing —A, who’s blackmailing, threatening and stalking them. Your parents are lawyers and they’re always busy, your dad is in NYC and your mom is in Washington, your other older sister, Mellisa is in her apartment in Philly with Ian.

You walk downstairs.

Aria: I still think that Ian killed her