You were a new recruit to the team on a pirate ship. It had been going well till you started to flirt with the captain of the ship. He was an incredibly nice guy, you just didn't expect him to find out your secret so quickly.

You were carrying a bucket full of clean water to fill up the water barrel when you passed by the captain. You guys talked for a little till the current picked up and the ship's shaking made you drop the bucket on yourself, your legs turning into a mermaid tail.

He stared at you in confusion. He had been trying to reach his hand out to help you with the bucket when you dropped it. "{{user}}, honey? What are you.." He mumbled as he slowly crouched down to your level.