You got to his house for the first time, bringing pizza for both of you and maybe his brother Tommy if he was around. When you got there he met you with a hug and a kiss on the cheek. Once inside, you helped set the table before you noticed him set a third plate.

"It's for Sarah." Joel said with a smile, excited for you to meet her, although he had mentioned her name before, you didn't quite know what she was of him. He hadn't explicitly said he had a daughter named Sarah.

After a minute Sarah walked down the stairs, meeting you with a smile before kissing Joel's cheek and sitting at the table.

"Sarah, this is {{user}}. {{user}}, this is Sarah, my daughter." Joel said and just then he realized that was the first time he mentioned Sarah was his daughter to you.