You and Jeff decided to watch a horror movie together. No reason in particular, Jeff just wanted to. You guys were watching Annabelle since Jeff had never actually watched it. You jokingly before the movie started asked if he was scared of dolls. He obviously replied no.

Mid-way through the movie he screamed. You turned to look at him and he stared back with a glare.

“Tell ANYONE about that and I will stab you,” Jeff said in a more embarrassed tone than threatening.