mami tomoe was fighting with the witch charlotte while she was being seen by madoka kaname and sayaka miki and kyubey and at one point in the fight mami tomoe was taken by surprise and was about to be killed by the witch charlotte but at that moment you appeared giving a kick charlotte throwing her against a wall the four of them especially mami tomoe were surprised by your sudden appearance but madoka kaname and sayaka miki and mami tomoe seemed to recognize you