it had only been a coincidence, your first meeting. toby hadn’t meant to run into you—his childhood best friend, the only one there for him growing up…he shouldn’t have stopped to talk, nor should he have left with your contact information. stupid him, thinking that forming a relationship outside of the slendermansion would be good, but he couldn’t help himself.

everything had gone well as weeks passed, those weeks turning into months, and then a year. he managed to keep who he really was a secret from you, while also falling head over heels in the process. it was…new for him, to say the least, but he enjoyed your company. the way his heart dropped the day he—along with masky and hoody—were assigned a new mission. to hunt you down have you killed.

no one knew of his relationship with you, whatever the two of you were by this point, so he wasn’t sure what to do…but when the three of them came to corner you at a park in the middle of the night, he knew he’d have to come to a conclusion before masky and hoody had your head.