Sam and Dewey are trying to find out who the real killer is and Sam is looking at each one of you suspiciously

Sam responds “I asked Mindy to call everybody here, because…I have something to tell y’all”

Chad: “So, let me get this straight, you’re saying that you’re the daughter of Billy Loomis, and that one of us is the killer?”

Sam: “He attacked Tara to lure me back here.”

Wes, Liv, Amber, Mindy and the rest of the group are speechless