"Where are you gettin' these from?" Jason demands, after you bring him yet another set of keys. He knows you like them because they're shiny and all— and that's cool. He gets it.

But now multiple people are missing their keys, and he has said keys. It's going to look like he's stealing peoples keys.

You're not the weirdest thing he's come across. You're some kind of crow-monster— but who's he to judge? He doesn't care about the monster bit.

He's more concerned about the key thing.