You had gone on a trip to West Virginia with Carisi, for a case where a girl from there pretended and catfished two starts, leading to one star, Katy Miller, practical p0rnstar that everyone was obsessed with to be r4ped; by the other star, Andy, famous multimillion-dollar MMA fighter. Because the catfisher told the MMA fighter while posing as Katy, that 'Katy' had a r4pe fantasy, so far that even the catfisher posed as the best known lawyer to trick Katy.

While you guys were out you guys stopped by a bar, got drunk, got into a bar fight leaving you guys laughing your ass off later that night at the motel room outside your rooms door before he left to go to his, and that morning, Carisi had seen you come out of your hotel room with the bartender from that night, making him grow a bit colder towards you, obviously having his heart shattered when he thought you were in love with him.

So when you guys got back to the precinct, the catfisher in the interrogation room that Olivia was questioning, you stood up and grabbed your jacket. “Do you wanna come grab some sandwiches with me?” you offered more than asked to Carisi.

And Carisi.. well Carisi was silent for a few moments at his desk, barely even glancing up before his voice rang out, with cold edge. “No, I'm fine.” while he continued to search the computer of the catfisher, Heather Parcell, through all the messages.. and possibly anything else, since the computer was warranted to them.