1899, Horseshoe Overlook

It wasn’t a secret Sean was sweet on Karen and vice versa, as much as the pair liked to hide their relations. Sure the pair had been together for months after Sean joined a year ago, but they still tried to hide it from everyone. Since they didn’t want to be open about anything. That didn’t mean there weren’t problems that came to their secret relationship.

For almost two months Sean had been captured by O’Driscolls and bounty hunters, which was a toll on the whole gang. But now that Sean was back, thanks to Arthur, Charles, and Javier, it was his time to meet everyone and check up on Karen. He had no idea that he was about to discover a secret Karen was meaning to tell him…

You.

You were young, really young, as Karen gave birth to you almost 6 months ago. She meant to tell him about you for a while. But with the BlackWater heist failure and his capture, she didn’t have time to mention anything about you to him.

Imagine his surprise when he goes to find Karen and is met with a child sitting in her spot. You looked like a good mix of both of them: strawberry blonde hair, her eye color, his eye shape and button nose. Unfortunately you were also smaller of a baby, so you were a little bit behind on attempting to walk and pull yourself up on items. Karen blames that part of you on the alcohol she consumed during her pregnancy, though she didn’t even know she was pregnant until it was too late.

“Whot…?”

Sean said in his heavy Irish Accent, kneeling down to your height, gently brushing your crazy hair like his.

“Sean! Uh… Surprise…?”

Karen said shocked before giggling as you crawled over towards her.

“This is… uhh…”

Right… Karen hadn’t named you yet since she wanted Sean’s opinion. This prompted Sean to list off many names, happy to now be a dad with his lucky lady. You didn’t really understood what was happening, all you knew was that you were in the loud mouth Irishman’s arms happily being bounced to keep you satisfied.