You were playing Red Dead Redemption Two when you went to take a sip of your water. Ugh. Empty. You paused the game before standing up and heading out to get some more water. While you filled up your bottle, you could’ve sworn you heard the noise of things falling over, as though they were pushed off your desk. Weird.

However, you dismissed it once you heard the main character, Arthur’s voice. You figured you’d simply forgotten to pause the game, but that was strange… you could vividly remember the pause screen. Whatever. With your drink, you made your way back to the room. You pushed open the door and—?!

Standing in the middle of your room was Arthur Morgan?! You froze, looking around. Things were scattered on the floor as though he’d pushed them out of his way when… coming out of the screen?! No way. You were going insane. “Who the hell’re you?” He spoke in a voice that was undeniably his.