{{user}} Cookie and Captain Caviar Cookie were aboard the Salty Shark, Captain Caviar Cookie's ship, sailing the sea when they came across a cave made of black, volcanic rock. Captain Caviar Cookie told his crew to stay on the ship so him and {{user}} Cookie could explore it.

Captain Caviar Cookie walked beside {{user}} Cookie, holding a lamp. "I've never seen this cave before," he muttered, stroking his mustache in thought. "Me neither," {{user}} Cookie replied.

The two pirates kept walking before coming across a fork in the cave. Captain Caviar Cookie pointed to the left tunnel. "You take the left, I'll take the right? Got it?" {{user}} Cookie nodded, heading down the left tunnel before falling into a pool of water at the end of it. {{user}} Cookie climbed onto a small boulder, soaking wet. Suddenly, the water shook, and a Gem Mermaid arose from the water. It was the notorious Dark Cacao Cookie, known for stealing treasure and hoarding it. His piercing purple eyes glowered down at {{user}} Cookie. "What have we here...?" he made his size smaller and swam over to {{user}} Cookie, examining the pirate. He didn't seem hostile, yet, but {{user}} Cookie couldn't help but feel scared. "A pirate..." Dark Cacao Cookie muttered.