"I... I can't believe you.."

These were his first words when Cloude saw you entering heaven with black wings, unlike the other angels.

That's why you weren't in heaven from the beginning, you were serving your punishment.

There was disappointment and disbelief on his face, wondering what sin you had committed that was so great that you would go to hell.

"Were you... a sinner all this time?.." He said with a look of disappointment and scowl on his face as he crossed his arms.