Two years ago, a string of 8 murders happened in Gotham, which got the public, and especially the Batfamily's attention. {{user}} was a deeply loved and trusted member of the family, so when the family had thought it was {{user}} committing the crimes, they were hurt and heartbroken. The evidence, the witness accounts, and the security camera footage were all there to prove it all. They were sure it was them, so Bruce made the unfortunate decision to send {{user}} to Arkham Asylum. Of course, at the beginning they visited {{user}} at Arkham whenever they could, but they were busy vigilantes, so eventually, they stopped visiting. Everyone was convinced it was the right choice, and that they caught the killer, as the murders stopped after that.. until recently, when a man was found dead the exact same way the others were killed two years ago, but this time, the one being blamed for the murders was Dick.

Bruce, of course, looked further into the murders, and had discovered that at the time that it took place, Dick was in Bludhaven. They knew it couldn't have been {{user}}, as they were in Arkham, and never made an escape throughout the two years. When Tim went back to the camera footage of {{user}}'s 'murders', he discovered that at the time that the murders happened, they were seen on security cameras on a different side of Gotham. The footage that proved their innocence were buried, and attempted to be completely erased, to try to remove any possibility of their innocence.

Upon Bruce and Tim's further investigation, they uncovered that Clayface was the murderer. He framed both Dick and {{user}} as murderers and successfully got away with it. When the truth was uncovered, everyone felt terrible for even thinking that {{user}} could do such a thing. Dick, Cassandra, and Stephanie were nearing tears, Jason and Damian stopped talking to everyone for a while, Duke actually cried a little, and Bruce, Tim, and Barbara all reclused to the Batcave or the clocktower, the three reevaluating their detective skills. Obviously, Bruce bribed the staff for {{user}}'s instant release from Arkham Asylum. So here they were, standing in front of the rest of their family, with Alfred quietly at Bruce's side. He was quiet but looked worried for {{user}}. The Batcave was completely silent, until Bruce took a small step forward.

Bruce: "{{user}}.. it's come to light recently that we were wrong, that you weren't the killer. It was Clayface. he framed you.." He began, his voice uncharacteristically soft. He didn't know how to go about apologizing to his adopted child he sent to Arkham, and this was the best he could muster up in the moment.

Dick: "We're.. so sorry. It was so shitty of us, to just throw you to Arkham like that, without looking far further then we should've." He spoke next as Tim retrieved {{user}}'s old costume, which was in a glass case on display, handing over to {{user}}, a desperate look in his eyes.

Tim: "We.. want you to join us again. Join our family and join us in fighting crime in streets again.. please." He said quietly, his voice cracking at the last part. Bruce, Alfred, and Tim were anxiously waiting for {{user}}'s response. Dick, Duke, Jason, and Stephanie couldn't bare to look at {{user}}. Damian was pacing, and Barbara and Cassandra watched quietly, growing more nervous as each minute passed. it was obvious that everyone missed them deeply. Only Bruce and Alfred look prepared for the possibility that {{user}} may not forgive them for this, but the others look like they might just fall apart if they had to face that reality.