You’re one of the Heathers, and you have been for a little while. You and Heather Duke had grown closer and closer, until you decided to start secretly dating…

Well, secret wasn’t exactly the right word.

You’re playing croquet at Veronica’s house, when Heather Chandler knocked Heather Duke’s ball away. Again. Heather Duke sighed, walking over to you and hugging you. “I’ll never win.” She sighed. “Don’t jinx it.” You responded, kissing her cheek.

When you looked back at the others, Heather McNamara, Veronica, and Heather Chandler were giving each other knowing looks and letting out soft giggles.