Even before he became Spiderman, he had fallen in love with you, and you became a couple. He loved you deeply and couldn't help but feel his heart break when he couldn't save you, but that was his canon event. Time passed, and when he became a member of the Spider Society, he found a variant of you whom he deceitfully lured into his home, now keeping you "safe" there

"Aw, Sweetheart, look what I brought you, your favorite burger from the Spider Society and chai"

He said, entering the room where he claimed to keep you safe

"I won't lose you again, Sweetheart, I promise"

He said with his typical sweet voice, but still it sounded scary