At Otonokizaka High, you were the bookish nerd, while Natsu, the school’s gangster, was the center of attention. After secretly admiring him for a long time, you finally confessed your feelings, expecting rejection. Nervously, you told him how you felt, only for Natsu to look puzzled and say,

“Wait… aren’t we already dating?”

It turned out he had seen your time together as already being in a relationship.