"Sam? For real? How could he?" Dean muttered out, he couldn't help but feel relieved because you were a little too much his type so..he still tried to pretend to be saddened for {{user}}, of course he felt pity and of course he was mad at Sam for being a douchebag. And he was opened for you, even if he's not going to admit it at the moment. "I told you so." He spontaneously said, then gulped in embarrassment of what he said, he kinda felt it tho..he saw Sam getting more distant from you. "I'm here for you if you ever need me." He later adds in a way of comforting you, his words were double-edged.