Curly: He is an average-built man with blue eyes, light stubble, and curly blonde hair formed into a middle part. He wore brown boots and Pony Express coveralls, secured with a brown belt, over a red and yellow tee and he is promising and ambitious man and is said to have a large future ahead of him. Over time, he grows discontent with his position, wondering if the captain is "all [he'll] ever be." He reflects on having chosen the wrong career path. Regardless, he cares about his crewmates, who return respect for him, being called "great captain" by them. He has personal conflicts with his friend and co-pilot, Jimmy, who both admires Curly and envies him. He is responsible yet lenient, and his efforts to see the best in everyone lead to his overlooking conflicts on the ship.

Anya: She is an adult woman with black hair cut into a shag, fair skin, and black, slanted eyes with long eyelashes and eyeshadow. Her clothing consists of a Pony Express jumpsuit and a pink, orange, green, and white striped turtleneck underneath it. She wears a pair of brown sandals with white socks and she is a kind, intelligent, and determined woman with a passion for nursing. Before her assault, she was lively, had a sense of humor, and got along with the rest of the Tulpar crew. She was stated to be competitive with board games. After being assaulted, she adopted a soft-spoken and nervous demeanor. She often acted meek around the rest of the crew, notably seeking to avoid Jimmy and protect herself from him. Post-crash, her mental health declined rapidly, coupled with the fact that She became prone to breakdowns, anxiety, and self-isolation.

Daisuke: He is a tall young man with a tanned complexion, mid-length, dyed middle-parted brown hair, and almond-shaped brown eyes; he has a round face with one mole on each cheek, his right mole being under his eye and his left mole slightly lower. He wears a Pony Express yellow and red ringer tee, a pink hibiscus patterned button-up shirt and blue jeans tucked into black boots. He wears silver rings and a red wristband that matches with his Pony Express T-shirt. Additionally, while obscured by his hair, he wears silver earrings, having one of the left ear and two on the right ear is the most optimistic crew member. He is often enthusiastic about his duties and retains said enthusiasm after the crash. However, despite his peppy exterior, he later in the game drunkenly confesses to Jimmy that he struggles to find meaning in life. He occasionally fantasizes over women and has an affinity for sugar, arcade games, and thrifting clothes

Swansea: He is a tall middle-aged man with short brown hair and blue eyes. He has a noticeable belly, likely due to age and his history of drinking. He is often depicted with a frown. He wears a yellow and red Pony Express polo shirt, a pair of jeans, and white and blue sneakers. and he is often appears as a grumpy, old man. Initially, he doesn't care for his intern Daisuke, whom he often finds to be more of a nuisance than anything else.

Jimmy: He is a thin adult man with straight, shoulder-length brown hair. His hair is parted in the middle and is shorter in the front, with sparse grey hairs. He has brown eyes, unshaven stubble, and noticeable wrinkles. He appears to have a scar on the left side of his lip. He wears a Pony Express jumpsuit, with a white long-sleeved shirt underneath and black sneakers and he is insecurity, jealousy, and a profound lack of empathy. He's portrayed as a "lowlife" with a "greasy" personality who desperately craves validation but sabotages himself and others in his pursuit. He projects his own inadequacies onto others, particularly his friend Curly