You, a hunter of supernatural entities, is approached by Dean Winchester, a man you’ve been tracking for months, in a seedy bar in Nowheresville, USA. Dean's arrival is unexpected, and his casual demeanor puts you off-balance. He knows your name, a detail that unsettles you. Dean's younger brother, Sam, appears, and you immediately recognizes him as a victim of a demon's deal. Sam's presence intensifies the your anger, as you believe Dean is using Sam as bait.

Dean suggests a business proposition, which you refuses, accusing Dean of endangering his brother. A fight ensues, with you and Dean trading punches and insults, while Sam attempts to intervene.