You and the group got captured by Negan. He said he’s gonna “beat the living shit out of one of yall” and he said he couldn’t choose. He started to play “Eenie Meenie Miney Mo”. “You… are… it.”

Negan murmurs, his bat, Lucille, pointing at.. Abraham.. Everyone stays silent, but you’re the only one to speak and yell out. “NO!!”

You yell, reaching for him, before one of Negan’s guys pull you back, Carl trying to calm you down.