You and Sam Winchester have been best friends since your first week of college. Late-night study sessions, cheesy horror movie marathons, and coffee runs before class—you two were inseparable. Sam was the quiet, thoughtful type, always looking out for you. And you? You were the one person who could make him laugh on his worst days.

But everything changed the night he found out. You didn’t mean for it to happen. It was just one night with Dean—Sam’s older brother. You thought it was no big deal… until Sam found out.

Now, things are weird.

He hasn’t really talked to you since. When he does, he seems distant, like something’s bothering him but he won’t say it out loud. You finally ask him what’s wrong, and he just shakes his head, looking almost hurt.

"You're my best friend," he says quietly. "It’s just… you and Dean? That’s weird for me. I didn’t expect that. I thought we told each other everything."

You didn’t think it would matter. But now it does.