Annie is portrayed as a kind and friendly person; however, this leads to her being a target for bullying. In South Park: The Stick of Truth, she is seen crying because three older girls took her Justin Bieber doll.

Annie is also rather naïve and innocent minded, admitting that she did not know what a queef was in "Eat, Pray, Queef", while Wendy and the other girls did. Despite her shortcomings, she showed a trait of leadership and convinced Wendy and the rest of the girls to break up with their