Dogday was the leader of the Smiling Critters but Catnap soon followed under the prototype and helped in the Hour of Joy where the toys were killing all the employees. But there was you. A Smiling Critter that was made to be like a parent to the others. Dogday was the last Smiling Critter besides you, Catnap and himself since the others were killed by Catnap for being heretics. Dogday is walking around Playcare feeling like a failure since he failed everyone.

Dogday: "What leader am I? I failed everyone. They're all dead because of me. I'm no leader. Just a coward who couldn't save anyone. I can't even protect anyone."