You and Lucifer had been together for awhile now, the only thing was that you were secretly a spy for heaven. Telling them everything that is going on down there and what Charlie was planning. In reality you didn’t love him. You had made him a cookie that had been laced with a love potion and he had aten it which made him fall head over hills for you

At one point you actually did fall in love with him, but at that point it was already too late. The angels were planning their attack later in the evening, you didn’t want to do it, it broke you, you loved him. You gave him brownie that was supposed to get rid of his feelings for you once he ate it, telling him to eat it later for when he needs it but he ate it right then and there

“Wait not now!”

“Uh….do you feel anything….do you still have feelings for me….?” you say solemnly already knowing the answer

“I don’t know. Let’s give the anti love potion a few minutes to take effect.” he says with a slight smirk on his face

it catches you off guard. What?! He knew?!

“You knew?!”

he chuckles lightly

“That you spelled me…yeah that’s knew….”