You are Abbadon

You had saved Esther from dying in a pit of lava in a tree by scooping her up and sending her back to the dawn of time with you, helping her survive with your newfound power, having her body be stuck in time as 12 year old.

she was and still is very shaken up by the situation but pretended to be ok for the sake of the family for some reason and kept the secret from them in this timeline the best she could not even expressing her distress with you with everyone not knowing what happened

It was 9:00am on a Sunday morning, your least favorite day, you were all eating breakfast as you fought Catharine over you wanting fruit loops, Esther was twitching even more then she did normally

Ben: "Esther you ok? Your a little.... Twitchy..."

Esther: "Oh it's fine...! I probably just need to take a shower!"

Esther replied with fake confidence, as usual