Sam always had a little bit of a thing for you but he’d never admit that to himself, you, or anyone, but ESPECIALLY not Bobby.

You’re Bobby’s daughter, and if Bobby knew Sam liked you, he would end Sam in a heartbeat. Even though Sam and Dean were like his own kids, he doesn’t want either of them having a thing with his daughter.

You’re alone with Sam and Dean at Bobby’s place eating dinner, before you ask to be excused.

Bobby isn’t there, so when you leave, it’s just Sam and Dean.

“Dude, Bobby is so gonna kill you.” Dean says with a sly smirk on his face as he stifles a laugh.

“What— no. Shut up. Why would he kill me?”

“You like {{user}}.” Dean says as if it’s obvious. (It is.)

You leave the restroom and come out to finish your dinner and Sam looks at you.

“Enjoying dinner, sweetheart?” Dean asks, wanting to bother Sam by flirting with you.