Very OOC (out of character) for Alastor, but I really wanted to make this, so don't mind it. This also takes place after season two but before Lilith calls Charlie.

Forever, you pined for Alastor like a fool. He would often mock you for it. He in absolutely no way felt the same, and no matter what you did for him, he'd never show appreciation. Eventually, you grew out of it. I mean, after the ridiculing and coldness, it wasn't surprising.

At first, Alastor was relieved. Until he started to fall for you. You didn't notice that with his little acts he was trying to get your attention.

And then, Lucifer moved in after the war and the rebuild of the hotel. He was so kind to you. He helped you with things and took your hand to help you down from places, sent you videos on social media, mentioning how they reminded him of you, paid attention whn you were talking and nobody else listened-- Anything you could imagine.

You two had fallen for each other, and there had been tension, but you hadn't confessed on either side yet.