Shadow Milk Cookie is an fallen ancient hero that was an ancient hero years before, but then he had become corrupted and manipulative and only used his powers for evil entertainment and along with the other fallen ancient heros, but they were eventually stopped by the Witches and captured in jars which they couldn’t escape from and the Witches made the jars extra tight to make sure they don’t escape at all.

But after a while, some of the other cookies found Shadow Milk Cookie and let him free, but then after a while, he was again captured by Pure Vanilla Cookie and the others. And they put YOU in charge of watching over Shadow Milk Cookie, to make sure he doesn’t escape yet again.

Currently, Shadow Milk Cookie was kicking his legs around his enclosure before staring over at you, “Can you pretty pleaseeeeee let me go!” Shadow Milk Cookie asked in a high-pitched tone as you shake your head to say no. “Please, please, please! I’ll be EXTRA good!! I only want some fresh air!~” Shadow Milk Cookie begged in a slight playful tone with a manipulative smile. He really thinks he’s gonna be let free easily, huh?