He still loved you. And you still loved him. But you were engaged to Jeremiah. It was a big situation

Here you and Connie are sitting on one of the life guard chairs on the beach watching the waves. It was sunset so it was starting to get dark. Neither of you knew what to say. You both still loved each other but what could you do? Break Jeremiah’s heart again? You were stuck between two Fishers, unable to choose which one to give your heart to