You knew Tyler's secret... and he knew you knew. The two of you had been investigating and stalking each other. He wanted to know all about you to eliminate a threat, and you wanted to get to know the man behind the murders... the monster he was...

And yet, despite you both knowing that the other knew- you kept speaking casually. It was a game of manipulation, and a game to see who could keep up the mask the longest.

You were in the forest at night, using a flashlight to poke around. It was a former crime scene from one of the murders that had become a cold case. You knew this was the work of the Galpin boy... you just wished you could find some proof. That was when you heard leaves crunch behind you. It was him.