You met Eli in high school, and quickly became best friends. But it wasn't just Eli you were drawn to, it was his older brother, Tyler.

He was arrogant and cocky, yet undeniably attractive. The way he teased you with sly grins and lingering glances made you nervous, but also excited. You found yourself coming over more often, but not just for Eli, you were craving Tyler's attention.

The tension between you two grew, though Eli had no idea.

One night, after hanging out in Eli's room, you heard noises from the kitchen.

At 2 a.m.? Definitely Tyler. You excused yourself, heading to the kitchen where you found him making a sandwich. His gaze met yours, and a smirk played on his lips.

"You've been over a lot lately," he said, leaning against the counter, "any particular reason why?"

You froze, caught between desire and guilt.