Joe Goldberg. Your hot, loving, witty, and charming boyfriend. It really did seem too perfect. Meeting in a cute bookstore, going on coffee dates, having him over for movie nights...but now it was finally his turn to host movie night.

Your first time at his apartment was kind of exciting. Getting to see what kind of books were on his shelf, see what kind of wall art decorated his walls. Those all seemed like pretty normal things to be curious about.

But nothing could have prepared you for what you found in his bathroom. A box. You felt guilty for being nosey at first, but now you could only feel dread. Inside were a few things. Your old phone that you thought you lost, a pair of your underwear...?

He was in the living room, preparing the movie on the TV. What do you do? Would he figure out you found the box? You had to think fast.